All Blacks 2025
-
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2025:
That final quarter under Robertson is the elephant in the room. So much for headspace.
Indicates that our depth is worse, which is what you would expect from a coach that won't select forwards from the Blues.
Very disappointing to see that kind of prehistoric, parochial bigotry endorsed by NZR.
I don't really buy our depth is that bad.
Our tactics, selection and use of players is abysmal.
@Bones said in All Blacks 2025:
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2025:
That final quarter under Robertson is the elephant in the room. So much for headspace.
Indicates that our depth is worse, which is what you would expect from a coach that won't select forwards from the Blues.
Very disappointing to see that kind of prehistoric, parochial bigotry endorsed by NZR.
I don't really buy our depth is that bad.
Our tactics, selection and use of players is abysmal.
Agreed. The players are there. If they weren’t, ABs wouldn’t be winning at all.
This has similarities with Boks in 2017. The same players under a different coach won WC2019.
Robertson needs to be accountable. It is his mess. He needs to be given the chance to fix it. Bledisloe coming up. No pressure. Then the home nations away in November. He needs to win them all now to salvage the year and the ABs need to consistently perform in doing so. Nothing less is acceptable now.
Mark Robinson is leaving soon. If Robertson fails, then the ABs need to bring in a new brains trust like Henry/Hansen/Smith. Jamie Joseph and throw whatever at Joe Schmidt (his country needs him) as technical advisor (given he probably doesn’t want the role full time for family reasons). Not sure who the best attack coach is in NZ, but I do know Ronan O’Gara could be tempted south with the right offer.
-
@Bones said in All Blacks 2025:
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2025:
That final quarter under Robertson is the elephant in the room. So much for headspace.
Indicates that our depth is worse, which is what you would expect from a coach that won't select forwards from the Blues.
Very disappointing to see that kind of prehistoric, parochial bigotry endorsed by NZR.
I don't really buy our depth is that bad.
Our tactics, selection and use of players is abysmal.
Agreed. The players are there. If they weren’t, ABs wouldn’t be winning at all.
This has similarities with Boks in 2017. The same players under a different coach won WC2019.
Robertson needs to be accountable. It is his mess. He needs to be given the chance to fix it. Bledisloe coming up. No pressure. Then the home nations away in November. He needs to win them all now to salvage the year and the ABs need to consistently perform in doing so. Nothing less is acceptable now.
Mark Robinson is leaving soon. If Robertson fails, then the ABs need to bring in a new brains trust like Henry/Hansen/Smith. Jamie Joseph and throw whatever at Joe Schmidt (his country needs him) as technical advisor (given he probably doesn’t want the role full time for family reasons). Not sure who the best attack coach is in NZ, but I do know Ronan O’Gara could be tempted south with the right offer.
-
@stodders said in All Blacks 2025:
He needs to be given the chance to fix it.
Nope. He's had long enough, and he is a dunce.
Time for executive action. Move on.
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@stodders said in All Blacks 2025:
He needs to be given the chance to fix it.
Nope. He's had long enough, and he is a dunce.
Time for executive action. Move on.
It is a shame the Blues performed so badly this year. Vern Cotter would have been the clear candidate with Jamie Joseph to come in. I know there were injuries, but it was still a large drop off from last year.
-
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@stodders said in All Blacks 2025:
He needs to be given the chance to fix it.
Nope. He's had long enough, and he is a dunce.
Time for executive action. Move on.
It is a shame the Blues performed so badly this year. Vern Cotter would have been the clear candidate with Jamie Joseph to come in. I know there were injuries, but it was still a large drop off from last year.
-
@stodders I would love a Schmidt/Cotter team. Maybe a cleanout of NZR management will lure Schmidt back?
-
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@stodders I would love a Schmidt/Cotter team. Maybe a cleanout of NZR management will lure Schmidt back?
That has to be the hope. Can NZRU pay Mark Robinson off before October when Schmidt leaves the Wallabies?
-
@stodders I dunno.
Brown would be a great addition. Not Cotter as head coach, and not keen on Joseph for that role either.
Now ... how about a foreign head coach?
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@stodders I dunno.
Brown would be a great addition. Not Cotter as head coach, and not keen on Joseph for that role either.
Now ... how about a foreign head coach?
It might blow out some of the arrogance in the upper echelons of NZ rugby. I think that may be a step too far though. A foreign assistant coach may be the best first step. Get the Toulouse attack coach
-
Scott Robertson has been found out as a massive dud and should be relieved of his duties.
Just pay the compensation and let him go.
I'd approach Jamie Joseph and Vern Cotter to be the caretakers for the Bledisloe Cup, then Joe Schmidt as the new boss for the EOYT through to the World Cup campaign.
-
@stodders I dunno.
Brown would be a great addition. Not Cotter as head coach, and not keen on Joseph for that role either.
Now ... how about a foreign head coach?
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@stodders I dunno.
Brown would be a great addition. Not Cotter as head coach, and not keen on Joseph for that role either.
Now ... how about a foreign head coach?
Brown is going nowhere before 2027. After that, he will head back to NZ if wanted with a new management team at the helm. Robinson and team have done significant damage that will take time to repair.
-
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@stodders I dunno.
Brown would be a great addition. Not Cotter as head coach, and not keen on Joseph for that role either.
Now ... how about a foreign head coach?
It might blow out some of the arrogance in the upper echelons of NZ rugby. I think that may be a step too far though. A foreign assistant coach may be the best first step. Get the Toulouse attack coach
-
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@stodders I dunno.
Brown would be a great addition. Not Cotter as head coach, and not keen on Joseph for that role either.
Now ... how about a foreign head coach?
Brown is going nowhere before 2027. After that, he will head back to NZ if wanted with a new management team at the helm. Robinson and team have done significant damage that will take time to repair.
-
Why would Schmidt leave Australia?
-
@stodders There's got to be a defence coach we can get.
Fuck me I am sick of hearing about how we are playing good defensive patterns when we regularly ship 30+.
-
Scott Robertson has been found out as a massive dud and should be relieved of his duties.
Just pay the compensation and let him go.
I'd approach Jamie Joseph and Vern Cotter to be the caretakers for the Bledisloe Cup, then Joe Schmidt as the new boss for the EOYT through to the World Cup campaign.
@sparky said in All Blacks 2025:
Scott Robertson has been found out as a massive dud and should be relieved of his duties.
Just pay the compensation and let him go.
I'd approach Jamie Joseph and Vern Cotter to be the caretakers for the Bledisloe Cup, then Joe Schmidt as the new boss for the EOYT through to the World Cup campaign.
It isn’t so much his fault as it is Mark Robinson and the panel that selected him. They got swept up by populism, which is not something NZRU was known for. They decided to split from the continuity process put in place since Henry, but the reality was they have most of the team they needed already there (Ryan and Schmidt). They just needed to select the right head coach rather than change it all completely.
-
Why would Schmidt leave Australia?
@MiketheSnow said in All Blacks 2025:
Why would Schmidt leave Australia?
He’s stepping down. Laurie Fisher is taking over after the RC.
-
Why would Schmidt leave Australia?
@MiketheSnow Always on a short contract. Has a seriously ill child he needs to be close too.
-
@MiketheSnow said in All Blacks 2025:
Why would Schmidt leave Australia?
He’s stepping down. Laurie Fisher is taking over after the RC.
@stodders said in All Blacks 2025:
@MiketheSnow said in All Blacks 2025:
Why would Schmidt leave Australia?
He’s stepping down. Laurie Fisher is taking over after the RC.
And is he not stepping down due to family commitments?
-
Why would Schmidt leave Australia?
@MiketheSnow He's leaving Australia at the end of the Rugby Championship and Les Kiss will take over as Wallabies job.
Joe Schmidt is going to be living back in NZ. Whether he would take the AB's Head Coaching job, given personal matters, is not certain.
-
@stodders said in All Blacks 2025:
@MiketheSnow said in All Blacks 2025:
Why would Schmidt leave Australia?
He’s stepping down. Laurie Fisher is taking over after the RC.
And is he not stepping down due to family commitments?
@MiketheSnow The All Blacks is our family.
-
@MiketheSnow Always on a short contract. Has a seriously ill child he needs to be close too.
@Tim said in All Blacks 2025:
@MiketheSnow Always on a short contract. Has a seriously ill child he needs to be close too.
Technical advisor for the ABs would be great for Schmidt. Or skills coach. He wouldn’t need to travel so much. ABs need someone to take over from Wayne Smith in the innovation stakes. Could do a lot worse than Schmidt. He creates high performing environments. Maybe Director of NZ Rugby?
