All Blacks 2025
-
@mohikamo said in All Blacks 2025:
Alejandro Iachetti
Didn't he have a twin? Lot of good it did them back in the day.
I'll throw in Skelton in the big bastard category. Only this year for some reason he's all of a sudden selectable. Complete liability prior to this season.
-
@canefan said in All Blacks 2025:
Razor values speed and trickery over power.
Explains George Bridge at the Crusaders.
-
@ploughboy said in All Blacks 2025:
@akan004 said in All Blacks 2025:
Are we big enough in the forwards? Our front row is but the Aussies had bigger men running at us from 4-8 and were bending the line on most occasions. Our obsession with mobility and speed in NZ rugby has resulted in us not producing large forwards. I look at the NPC and our loosies are all virtually the same size, sitting around the 110kg mark and our locks aren't massive. We saw what a bigger body like Patty T could do when he came on, and that's where the game is heading now - power and size.
A decade ago, we could rely on our players running the opposition off their feet and our pack, while not being the largest, were always the quickest and most skilled, which gave us an advantage. Now, the opposition is as skilled, as fit and they generally have bigger men than us, while the introduction of impact players means that they will always have fresh forwards to close the game out.
It's not a question of us not being able to produce big guys. We do have the largest PI population in the world so size shouldn't be an issue, it's just that we tend to pick guys to suit the traditional NZ speed game which has always favoured slightly smaller men. Guys like Skelton, LSL, Meafou, the Vunipola brothers, Antonio etc are all NZ born, so we certainly can produce bigger athletes. We just need to start identifying them and bringing them through.
agree with you on size at 6 and eight
at 7 papalii and Jacobson arnt small and even savea is ok but the lakais and kirifis arelocks hopefully will have lord and Darryl with sa and tengblad coming through
Vakasiuola is the biggest young lock to emerge. He is a huge guy, so is his brother (THP).
-
-
A brother, Marco I think. He was big too, but not as big as Alex.
The Argentine scrum back then was legendary, in fact you could probably say that they were the inspiration for the modern day power scrum.
They could play back then too. Beat SA at Bloemfontein in '82.
Hugo Porta scored all the points.Porta held the international points scoring record for some time.
-
@canefan said in All Blacks 2025:
But in rugby you can't play with speed unless you have the strength to win the contest for the ball. And with today's rules you can't run teams off their feet
Hit the nail right on the head there.
NZ will be able to beat most teams by running them around, but when they come against a team with a big power game that can win the contest for the ball, they wont be able to run them off their feet, and we'll find them very difficult to deal with.
Black Ferns ran into that a week ago.
Very predictably they struggled as soon as they came up against a well drilled ball contest team.
The NZ U20s have the same issues.The rules make it possible for a power team to slow the game down.
But WR do seem to be working on that.
5 second rule.
Scrum clock.
Goalkick clock.
No scrum resets.
etc.
You'd think all the little rule adjustments like that will be incremently speeding the game up.
Which will be to our advantage.
In the meantime . . .Assuming big Will plays on the weekend, interesting to see how the game pans out.
He's been brought in for exactly this reason.
Used to be a big lump of uselessness, but maybe not anymore. -
-
@brodean said in All Blacks 2025:
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2025:
@nonpartizan said in All Blacks 2025:
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2025:
I disagree. Versus Bok 2 we were still in it with 20 minutes to play. Kolbe's intercept was a game changer.
We needed optimum side as stated above and active captain.With a functioning set piece (particularly lineout) that game could and would have been more competitive. I personally think they would still have won but it would have been by a much more respectable score.
I agree. Holland is such a lineout weapon (and a decent work rate) he has to start.
The lineout was so much better with Taylor and Holland there and with Scooter missing. Vaai and Tuipulotu are both better lineout callers than Scooter too.
Holland should be the first lock named and the main 80 minute player. Vaa'i can lose focus if he plays much longer than 60. Paddy, Scooter and Darry can fill in the gaps when they're not injured. I doubt any of those 3 have the bodies now for regular 80 minute test rugby
@brodean said in All Blacks 2025:
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2025:
@nonpartizan said in All Blacks 2025:
@BerniesCorner said in All Blacks 2025:
I disagree. Versus Bok 2 we were still in it with 20 minutes to play. Kolbe's intercept was a game changer.
We needed optimum side as stated above and active captain.With a functioning set piece (particularly lineout) that game could and would have been more competitive. I personally think they would still have won but it would have been by a much more respectable score.
I agree. Holland is such a lineout weapon (and a decent work rate) he has to start.
The lineout was so much better with Taylor and Holland there and with Scooter missing. Vaai and Tuipulotu are both better lineout callers than Scooter too.
Holland should be the first lock named and the main 80 minute player. Vaa'i can lose focus if he plays much longer than 60. Paddy, Scooter and Darry can fill in the gaps when they're not injured. I doubt any of those 3 have the bodies now for regular 80 minute test rugby
In terms of grunt we need Scooter or Paddy T to fill one of the locking positions against Boks or Frogs. Holland, Vaa’i and Darry to take the other position, which ought to be for 80. The twist being that Vaa’i can be at 6 for some of that, as required .
-
@Frank said in All Blacks 2025:
Who are the hardest running loose forwards in NZ?
As in full steam ahead in a straight line, no jinking.
Do we have any?5.5K views · 59 reactions | Big @will.stodart just BURST through 😤 📲...
Big @will.stodart just BURST through 😤 📲 Watch LIVE on @skysportnz
-
@Bones said in All Blacks 2025:
@Frank said in All Blacks 2025:
Who are the hardest running loose forwards in NZ?
As in full steam ahead in a straight line, no jinking.
Do we have any?Sounds like someone is searching for some Grace. No thanks
If he's the only one you can think of NZ is in trouble.
Can we get Kieran Read to come in and mentor someone on how to run it hard and straight ? ( and even at his absolute biggest he never clocked in more than 110kg or so )
-
@MN5 said in All Blacks 2025:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2025:
@Frank said in All Blacks 2025:
Who are the hardest running loose forwards in NZ?
As in full steam ahead in a straight line, no jinking.
Do we have any?Sounds like someone is searching for some Grace. No thanks
If he's the only one you can think of NZ is in trouble.
Can we get Kieran Read to come in and mentor someone on how to run it hard and straight ? ( and even at his absolute biggest he never clocked in more than 110kg or so )
Read wasn’t all power too, he had such a silky skill set. We miss having that combination
-
@jimmyb said in All Blacks 2025:
@MN5 said in All Blacks 2025:
@Bones said in All Blacks 2025:
@Frank said in All Blacks 2025:
Who are the hardest running loose forwards in NZ?
As in full steam ahead in a straight line, no jinking.
Do we have any?Sounds like someone is searching for some Grace. No thanks
If he's the only one you can think of NZ is in trouble.
Can we get Kieran Read to come in and mentor someone on how to run it hard and straight ? ( and even at his absolute biggest he never clocked in more than 110kg or so )
Read wasn’t all power too, he had such a silky skill set. We miss having that combination
Yeah he was a fantastic hybrid on attack. I had my doubts the very first time he replaced the legendary JC in the All Blacks ( a skinny looking white guy vs a Polynesian powerhouse ) but he well and truly won me over.
-
@canefan said in All Blacks 2025:
Is some of the problem intent? I seem to recall Wallace running pretty hard in the games in SA last year for example. They just need to be told to run hard and straight by the coaches
I don't think so. Sititi was playing wider in the 6 role, so running against smaller guys typically. And he's a quick feet at the line guy, not a power runner. I think his worst test last year was at 8, even though that is supposedly his favoured position. Add that to being fast-tracked back from injury, and you have what we've got now.
Finau is probably the only guy who is big, powerful, fast enough to wind up and run straight at the defence and expect to make metres. I wouldn't be averse to giving him a run at 8 and just telling him to do that for 40 (and that Harry Wilson said he was a pussy), as I'm not convinced Vaai or Parker are dynamic or powerful enough. Wallace on a flank to play the wide role he did so well last year, Dalton or Blackadder on the other flank to hit rucks and make tackles. Savea to the bench, to come on and take up the captaincy when Taylor goes off. -
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2025:
@canefan said in All Blacks 2025:
Is some of the problem intent? I seem to recall Wallace running pretty hard in the games in SA last year for example. They just need to be told to run hard and straight by the coaches
I don't think so. Sititi was playing wider in the 6 role, so running against smaller guys typically. And he's a quick feet at the line guy, not a power runner. I think his worst test last year was at 8, even though that is supposedly his favoured position. Add that to being fast-tracked back from injury, and you have what we've got now.
Finau is probably the only guy who is big, powerful, fast enough to wind up and run straight at the defence and expect to make metres. I wouldn't be averse to giving him a run at 8 and just telling him to do that for 40 (and that Harry Wilson said he was a pussy), as I'm not convinced Vaai or Parker are dynamic or powerful enough. Wallace on a flank to play the wide role he did so well last year, Dalton or Blackadder on the other flank to hit rucks and make tackles. Savea to the bench, to come on and take up the captaincy when Taylor goes off.Really ?
I thought his selling point was all the big hits he makes on defence ( which he hasn’t really shown at test level )
-
@MN5 said in All Blacks 2025:
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2025:
@canefan said in All Blacks 2025:
Is some of the problem intent? I seem to recall Wallace running pretty hard in the games in SA last year for example. They just need to be told to run hard and straight by the coaches
I don't think so. Sititi was playing wider in the 6 role, so running against smaller guys typically. And he's a quick feet at the line guy, not a power runner. I think his worst test last year was at 8, even though that is supposedly his favoured position. Add that to being fast-tracked back from injury, and you have what we've got now.
Finau is probably the only guy who is big, powerful, fast enough to wind up and run straight at the defence and expect to make metres. I wouldn't be averse to giving him a run at 8 and just telling him to do that for 40 (and that Harry Wilson said he was a pussy), as I'm not convinced Vaai or Parker are dynamic or powerful enough. Wallace on a flank to play the wide role he did so well last year, Dalton or Blackadder on the other flank to hit rucks and make tackles. Savea to the bench, to come on and take up the captaincy when Taylor goes off.Really ?
I thought his selling point was all the big hits he makes on defence ( which he hasn’t really shown at test level )
Well I am only talking about one thing: can you name someone who is as big and fast and powerful - who matches up with Wiese, Matera, Wilson?
Here are some who aren't: Savea, Sititi, Jacobson, Vaai, Parker, Kirifi, Lakai, Papalii, Blackadder, Lio-Willie, S Barrett. -
@reprobate Probably Miracle Fai’ilagi if he was eligible.
-
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2025:
Well I am only talking about one thing: can you name someone who is as big and fast and powerful - who matches up with Wiese, Matera, Wilson?
Here are some who aren't: Savea, Sititi, Jacobson, Vaai, Parker, Kirifi, Lakai, Papalii, Blackadder, Lio-Willie, S Barrett.Akira Ioane
-
@upthelanders said in All Blacks 2025:
@reprobate Probably Miracle Fai’ilagi if he was eligible.
Agree yep, but he's not. He and Tupou Ta'eiloa (sp?) - who might be too small for tests - are arguably the best ball runners in the country.
-
@nostrildamus said in All Blacks 2025:
@reprobate said in All Blacks 2025:
Well I am only talking about one thing: can you name someone who is as big and fast and powerful - who matches up with Wiese, Matera, Wilson?
Here are some who aren't: Savea, Sititi, Jacobson, Vaai, Parker, Kirifi, Lakai, Papalii, Blackadder, Lio-Willie, S Barrett.Akira Ioane
Nah, he's definitely not that guy. Powerful absolutely, but as a ball runner he is a wrestler not a smasher - that's actually why I think Frizzell was preferred over him.
