Skip to content
  • Categories
Collapse

The Silver Fern

  • Tipping
  • Team Sheets
  • Highlights
  • Results
    • All Blacks

      Search every All Blacks Test. Filter results by year, opposition, location, venue, city and RWC stage

    • Super Rugby

      Search every Super Rugby since match 1996

    • NPC

      Search NPC results. Only first division matches from 1976-2005. All results from the 14 team competition (2006-present) are included

All Blacks 2025

Scheduled Pinned Locked Moved Sports Talk
allblacks
9.3k Posts 152 Posters 552.1k Views 4 Watching
  • Oldest to Newest
  • Newest to Oldest
  • Most Votes
Reply
  • Reply as topic
Log in to reply
This topic has been deleted. Only users with topic management privileges can see it.
  • KiwiMurphK KiwiMurph

    @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

    @Bones said in All Blacks 2025:

    @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

    I am genuinely curious, what do these "bold" selections actually look like? Wallace Sititi and Pasilio Tosi were both very bold picks.

    See, for me this is concerning. We've got so used to mediocrity that selecting absolute stand out form players and only getting them on the field if injury strikes, is considered very bold.

    Sititi showed good form, but hardly put in a body of work that said he was an All Black for the here and now. As for Tosi - was he on anyone's radar?

    Sititi's performance in the semi final vs the Canes was about as obvious of a 'pick me I'm All Black material' as it gets - he was the best player on the field by a country mile.

    Canes4lifeC Offline
    Canes4lifeC Offline
    Canes4life
    wrote on last edited by Canes4life
    #2323

    @KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2025:

    @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

    @Bones said in All Blacks 2025:

    @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

    I am genuinely curious, what do these "bold" selections actually look like? Wallace Sititi and Pasilio Tosi were both very bold picks.

    See, for me this is concerning. We've got so used to mediocrity that selecting absolute stand out form players and only getting them on the field if injury strikes, is considered very bold.

    Sititi showed good form, but hardly put in a body of work that said he was an All Black for the here and now. As for Tosi - was he on anyone's radar?

    Sititi's performance in the semi final vs the Canes was about as obvious of a 'pick me I'm All Black material' as it gets - he was the best player on the field by a country mile.

    Yeah I remember thinking to myself in the stands watching that game 'who the fook is this guy' and why is he single handedly ruining our season. 😄

    1 Reply Last reply
    2
    • R Offline
      R Offline
      reprobate
      wrote on last edited by
      #2324

      As I remember it, there was a lot of crowing on here about how good our loose forward depth was last year pre-AB season. Then our loosies, as a unit, were consistently owned by just about everyone as far down as Argentina.
      That was with incumbent world player of the year Savea and soon-to-be breakout player of the year Sititi. And generally the tighties weren't too bad either - in fact no individual was playing really that badly - the balance was just wrong.
      The backs were a bit shit though. Pattern or players, whatever - if the players you pick can't play the pattern you want that's still a selection issue. Are we really going to suffer through another Beauden-Jordie-Ioane 'hi we're the backline for the world's greatest team but none of us can actually pass' year? Roigard better pick his act up too, based on his last game he'd just about make that list of can run can't pass.

      1 Reply Last reply
      2
      • KiwiMurphK KiwiMurph

        @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

        @Bones said in All Blacks 2025:

        @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

        I am genuinely curious, what do these "bold" selections actually look like? Wallace Sititi and Pasilio Tosi were both very bold picks.

        See, for me this is concerning. We've got so used to mediocrity that selecting absolute stand out form players and only getting them on the field if injury strikes, is considered very bold.

        Sititi showed good form, but hardly put in a body of work that said he was an All Black for the here and now. As for Tosi - was he on anyone's radar?

        Sititi's performance in the semi final vs the Canes was about as obvious of a 'pick me I'm All Black material' as it gets - he was the best player on the field by a country mile.

        frugbyF Offline
        frugbyF Offline
        frugby
        wrote on last edited by
        #2325

        @KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2025:

        @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

        @Bones said in All Blacks 2025:

        @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

        I am genuinely curious, what do these "bold" selections actually look like? Wallace Sititi and Pasilio Tosi were both very bold picks.

        See, for me this is concerning. We've got so used to mediocrity that selecting absolute stand out form players and only getting them on the field if injury strikes, is considered very bold.

        Sititi showed good form, but hardly put in a body of work that said he was an All Black for the here and now. As for Tosi - was he on anyone's radar?

        Sititi's performance in the semi final vs the Canes was about as obvious of a 'pick me I'm All Black material' as it gets - he was the best player on the field by a country mile.

        Sure, but I'd wager he was probably already in the squad before that game. I don't think a guy gets picked for the ABs based off one game.

        Canes4lifeC 1 Reply Last reply
        0
        • mariner4lifeM Offline
          mariner4lifeM Offline
          mariner4life
          wrote on last edited by
          #2326

          look, guys like Jacobson, Havili and Blackadder are really good rugby players. On top of this, Blackadder aside, they are showing good domestic form.

          My problem is, they have shown domestic form before, only to go on and prove to not be needle movers at test level. So why pick them again? what is the point? They're not different players this year, they are the same players in the same form. Picking them because experience and cover is about as conservative as you can get. They should be replaced by the new guys to see if they can be difference makers.

          Chris B.C 1 Reply Last reply
          9
          • frugbyF frugby

            @KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2025:

            @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

            @Bones said in All Blacks 2025:

            @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

            I am genuinely curious, what do these "bold" selections actually look like? Wallace Sititi and Pasilio Tosi were both very bold picks.

            See, for me this is concerning. We've got so used to mediocrity that selecting absolute stand out form players and only getting them on the field if injury strikes, is considered very bold.

            Sititi showed good form, but hardly put in a body of work that said he was an All Black for the here and now. As for Tosi - was he on anyone's radar?

            Sititi's performance in the semi final vs the Canes was about as obvious of a 'pick me I'm All Black material' as it gets - he was the best player on the field by a country mile.

            Sure, but I'd wager he was probably already in the squad before that game. I don't think a guy gets picked for the ABs based off one game.

            Canes4lifeC Offline
            Canes4lifeC Offline
            Canes4life
            wrote on last edited by Canes4life
            #2327

            @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

            @KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2025:

            @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

            @Bones said in All Blacks 2025:

            @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

            I am genuinely curious, what do these "bold" selections actually look like? Wallace Sititi and Pasilio Tosi were both very bold picks.

            See, for me this is concerning. We've got so used to mediocrity that selecting absolute stand out form players and only getting them on the field if injury strikes, is considered very bold.

            Sititi showed good form, but hardly put in a body of work that said he was an All Black for the here and now. As for Tosi - was he on anyone's radar?

            Sititi's performance in the semi final vs the Canes was about as obvious of a 'pick me I'm All Black material' as it gets - he was the best player on the field by a country mile.

            Sure, but I'd wager he was probably already in the squad before that game. I don't think a guy gets picked for the ABs based off one game.

            It's hard for me to comment on that, maybe a Chiefs fan can shed some light, but I don't recall him playing the house down before that game. I also remember Razor saying in an interview when the initial squad was selected that a couple players shone in the playoffs that caught his eye, so to me that means Sititi made a late claim and was picked after ignore based on his block busting game against the Canes. Any excuse not to pick Sotutu as well was probably a factor and also don't forget Brayden Iose was also in the conversation after a big season before Sititi completely outplayed him.

            boobooB 1 Reply Last reply
            0
            • Canes4lifeC Canes4life

              @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

              @KiwiMurph said in All Blacks 2025:

              @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

              @Bones said in All Blacks 2025:

              @frugby said in All Blacks 2025:

              I am genuinely curious, what do these "bold" selections actually look like? Wallace Sititi and Pasilio Tosi were both very bold picks.

              See, for me this is concerning. We've got so used to mediocrity that selecting absolute stand out form players and only getting them on the field if injury strikes, is considered very bold.

              Sititi showed good form, but hardly put in a body of work that said he was an All Black for the here and now. As for Tosi - was he on anyone's radar?

              Sititi's performance in the semi final vs the Canes was about as obvious of a 'pick me I'm All Black material' as it gets - he was the best player on the field by a country mile.

              Sure, but I'd wager he was probably already in the squad before that game. I don't think a guy gets picked for the ABs based off one game.

              It's hard for me to comment on that, maybe a Chiefs fan can shed some light, but I don't recall him playing the house down before that game. I also remember Razor saying in an interview when the initial squad was selected that a couple players shone in the playoffs that caught his eye, so to me that means Sititi made a late claim and was picked after ignore based on his block busting game against the Canes. Any excuse not to pick Sotutu as well was probably a factor and also don't forget Brayden Iose was also in the conversation after a big season before Sititi completely outplayed him.

              boobooB Offline
              boobooB Offline
              booboo
              wrote on last edited by booboo
              #2328

              @Canes4life said in All Blacks 2025:

              based on his block busting game against the Canes. ... Iose ...

              I detect a pattern

              1 Reply Last reply
              2
              • Canes4lifeC Offline
                Canes4lifeC Offline
                Canes4life
                wrote on last edited by
                #2329

                Sititi signs on through to the WC, great news for NZ Rugby.

                https://www.instagram.com/p/DJ2JszvzzgK/?utm_source=ig_web_copy_link&igsh=MzRlODBiNWFlZA==

                1 Reply Last reply
                3
                • Canes4lifeC Offline
                  Canes4lifeC Offline
                  Canes4life
                  wrote on last edited by
                  #2330

                  Some good news for the upcoming French series.

                  The president of the Fédération Française de Rugby (FFR) has brushed off claims of a France ‘B’ team touring New Zealand in July, giving the strongest indication yet that “exceptions are possible” for some French stars involved in the Top 14 final.

                  https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360695274/french-rugby-boss-says-les-bleus-stars-could-tour-they-target-series-win-against-all-blacks

                  boobooB 1 Reply Last reply
                  2
                  • nzzpN nzzp

                    @KiwiMurph said in Moana Pasifika v Blues:

                    @booboo said in Moana Pasifika v Blues:

                    Who on earth has thought that "Ardie is not All Black level" in the last nine years?

                    Plenty suggested he didn't play that well last year. And they were right.

                    Definition of a straw man argument

                    and it drives particular balance requirements in the other two loosies.

                    The issue was not with Ardie, it was Ardie + Sam Cane left an awful lot for the 6 to do ... you needed peak Kaino to try to balance it up.

                    Our loose forwards have not been super impressive over the last few years

                    R Offline
                    R Offline
                    reprobate
                    wrote on last edited by
                    #2331

                    @nzzp said in Moana Pasifika v Blues:

                    @KiwiMurph said in Moana Pasifika v Blues:

                    @booboo said in Moana Pasifika v Blues:

                    Who on earth has thought that "Ardie is not All Black level" in the last nine years?

                    Plenty suggested he didn't play that well last year. And they were right.

                    Definition of a straw man argument

                    and it drives particular balance requirements in the other two loosies.

                    The issue was not with Ardie, it was Ardie + Sam Cane left an awful lot for the 6 to do ... you needed peak Kaino to try to balance it up.

                    Our loose forwards have not been super impressive over the last few years

                    Yes. Our loosies have been a bit shit, less than the sum of their parts - and it all started with Foster making Cane captain, when Savea was the better 7. That forced Savea from 7 to 8, with both of them undroppable, and left us with no balance.
                    7 has always been his best position.

                    boobooB NepiaN 2 Replies Last reply
                    3
                    • mariner4lifeM mariner4life

                      look, guys like Jacobson, Havili and Blackadder are really good rugby players. On top of this, Blackadder aside, they are showing good domestic form.

                      My problem is, they have shown domestic form before, only to go on and prove to not be needle movers at test level. So why pick them again? what is the point? They're not different players this year, they are the same players in the same form. Picking them because experience and cover is about as conservative as you can get. They should be replaced by the new guys to see if they can be difference makers.

                      Chris B.C Offline
                      Chris B.C Offline
                      Chris B.
                      wrote on last edited by Chris B.
                      #2332

                      @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                      One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                      But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                      It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                      Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                      The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.

                      Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                      And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                      NepiaN R mariner4lifeM 3 Replies Last reply
                      2
                      • Chris B.C Chris B.

                        @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                        One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                        But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                        It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                        Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                        The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.

                        Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                        And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                        NepiaN Offline
                        NepiaN Offline
                        Nepia
                        wrote on last edited by Nepia
                        #2333

                        @Chris-B said in All Blacks 2025:

                        @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                        One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                        But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                        It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                        **Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                        The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.**

                        Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                        And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                        The journeymen were surrounded by the shinies in 2011 in McCaw, Nonu, Smith, Read, Kaino etc ... so let's not go too far down that track Mitch. 😉

                        In 2007we lost two 10s in the match, and the superstar GOAT subsequently admitted that we made the error of not setting for a droppie and instead played for a penalty.

                        Chris B.C 1 Reply Last reply
                        3
                        • Chris B.C Chris B.

                          @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                          One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                          But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                          It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                          Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                          The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.

                          Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                          And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                          R Offline
                          R Offline
                          reprobate
                          wrote on last edited by
                          #2334

                          @Chris-B first bok test last year, wasn't it one of the most experienced guys (Ofa) from the bench who got the yellow card?

                          Chris B.C 1 Reply Last reply
                          0
                          • R reprobate

                            @Chris-B first bok test last year, wasn't it one of the most experienced guys (Ofa) from the bench who got the yellow card?

                            Chris B.C Offline
                            Chris B.C Offline
                            Chris B.
                            wrote on last edited by Chris B.
                            #2335

                            @reprobate It was. But, we also botched a lineout and gave away a dumb penalty to piggyback the Boks up the field.

                            1 Reply Last reply
                            2
                            • Canes4lifeC Canes4life

                              Some good news for the upcoming French series.

                              The president of the Fédération Française de Rugby (FFR) has brushed off claims of a France ‘B’ team touring New Zealand in July, giving the strongest indication yet that “exceptions are possible” for some French stars involved in the Top 14 final.

                              https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360695274/french-rugby-boss-says-les-bleus-stars-could-tour-they-target-series-win-against-all-blacks

                              boobooB Offline
                              boobooB Offline
                              booboo
                              wrote on last edited by
                              #2336

                              @Canes4life said in All Blacks 2025:

                              Some good news for the upcoming French series.

                              The president of the Fédération Française de Rugby (FFR) has brushed off claims of a France ‘B’ team touring New Zealand in July, giving the strongest indication yet that “exceptions are possible” for some French stars involved in the Top 14 final.

                              https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360695274/french-rugby-boss-says-les-bleus-stars-could-tour-they-target-series-win-against-all-blacks

                              Realistically how many?

                              Compare to an All Black Team without C, say, Chiefs and Saders.

                              Groot
                              Aumua
                              Lomax
                              Paddy T
                              Holland
                              Kirifi
                              Iose
                              Lakai
                              Roigard
                              Barrett
                              Clarke
                              Barrett
                              Ioane/ Proctor
                              Telea/Lam
                              Love

                              ?
                              ?
                              Tosi
                              ?
                              Savea / Papalii
                              Christie (I know)
                              Tavatavanawai / Lam / Tangitau / Taele

                              Canes4lifeC Chris B.C 2 Replies Last reply
                              0
                              • boobooB booboo

                                @Canes4life said in All Blacks 2025:

                                Some good news for the upcoming French series.

                                The president of the Fédération Française de Rugby (FFR) has brushed off claims of a France ‘B’ team touring New Zealand in July, giving the strongest indication yet that “exceptions are possible” for some French stars involved in the Top 14 final.

                                https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360695274/french-rugby-boss-says-les-bleus-stars-could-tour-they-target-series-win-against-all-blacks

                                Realistically how many?

                                Compare to an All Black Team without C, say, Chiefs and Saders.

                                Groot
                                Aumua
                                Lomax
                                Paddy T
                                Holland
                                Kirifi
                                Iose
                                Lakai
                                Roigard
                                Barrett
                                Clarke
                                Barrett
                                Ioane/ Proctor
                                Telea/Lam
                                Love

                                ?
                                ?
                                Tosi
                                ?
                                Savea / Papalii
                                Christie (I know)
                                Tavatavanawai / Lam / Tangitau / Taele

                                Canes4lifeC Offline
                                Canes4lifeC Offline
                                Canes4life
                                wrote on last edited by
                                #2337

                                @booboo said in All Blacks 2025:

                                @Canes4life said in All Blacks 2025:

                                Some good news for the upcoming French series.

                                The president of the Fédération Française de Rugby (FFR) has brushed off claims of a France ‘B’ team touring New Zealand in July, giving the strongest indication yet that “exceptions are possible” for some French stars involved in the Top 14 final.

                                https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360695274/french-rugby-boss-says-les-bleus-stars-could-tour-they-target-series-win-against-all-blacks

                                Realistically how many?

                                Compare to an All Black Team without C, say, Chiefs and Saders.

                                Groot
                                Aumua
                                Lomax
                                Paddy T
                                Holland
                                Kirifi
                                Iose
                                Lakai
                                Roigard
                                Barrett
                                Clarke
                                Barrett
                                Ioane/ Proctor
                                Telea/Lam
                                Love

                                ?
                                ?
                                Tosi
                                ?
                                Savea / Papalii
                                Christie (I know)
                                Tavatavanawai / Lam / Tangitau / Taele

                                I think Du Pont is injured, but hopefully Romain Ntamack, Damian Penaud and Louis Bielle-Biarrey come across.

                                1 Reply Last reply
                                0
                                • NepiaN Nepia

                                  @Chris-B said in All Blacks 2025:

                                  @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                                  One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                                  But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                                  It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                                  **Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                                  The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.**

                                  Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                                  And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                                  The journeymen were surrounded by the shinies in 2011 in McCaw, Nonu, Smith, Read, Kaino etc ... so let's not go too far down that track Mitch. 😉

                                  In 2007we lost two 10s in the match, and the superstar GOAT subsequently admitted that we made the error of not setting for a droppie and instead played for a penalty.

                                  Chris B.C Offline
                                  Chris B.C Offline
                                  Chris B.
                                  wrote on last edited by
                                  #2338

                                  @Nepia said in All Blacks 2025:

                                  @Chris-B said in All Blacks 2025:

                                  @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                                  One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                                  But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                                  It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                                  **Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                                  The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.**

                                  Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                                  And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                                  The journeymen were surrounded by the shinies in 2011 in McCaw, Nonu, Smith, Read, Kaino etc ... so let's not go too far down that track Mitch. 😉

                                  Do you still own that half acre section at Cape Canaveral that's designated as the Andy Ellis Memorial Launchpad? 🙂

                                  BonesB 1 Reply Last reply
                                  2
                                  • Chris B.C Chris B.

                                    @Nepia said in All Blacks 2025:

                                    @Chris-B said in All Blacks 2025:

                                    @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                                    One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                                    But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                                    It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                                    **Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                                    The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.**

                                    Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                                    And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                                    The journeymen were surrounded by the shinies in 2011 in McCaw, Nonu, Smith, Read, Kaino etc ... so let's not go too far down that track Mitch. 😉

                                    Do you still own that half acre section at Cape Canaveral that's designated as the Andy Ellis Memorial Launchpad? 🙂

                                    BonesB Offline
                                    BonesB Offline
                                    Bones
                                    wrote on last edited by
                                    #2339

                                    @Chris-B said in All Blacks 2025:

                                    @Nepia said in All Blacks 2025:

                                    @Chris-B said in All Blacks 2025:

                                    @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                                    One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                                    But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                                    It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                                    **Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                                    The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.**

                                    Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                                    And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                                    The journeymen were surrounded by the shinies in 2011 in McCaw, Nonu, Smith, Read, Kaino etc ... so let's not go too far down that track Mitch. 😉

                                    Do you still own that half acre section at Cape Canaveral that's designated as the Andy Ellis Memorial Launchpad? 🙂

                                    It's fallen into disrepair after a maintenance contract was awarded to Blackadder Corp.

                                    1 Reply Last reply
                                    5
                                    • boobooB booboo

                                      @Canes4life said in All Blacks 2025:

                                      Some good news for the upcoming French series.

                                      The president of the Fédération Française de Rugby (FFR) has brushed off claims of a France ‘B’ team touring New Zealand in July, giving the strongest indication yet that “exceptions are possible” for some French stars involved in the Top 14 final.

                                      https://www.stuff.co.nz/sport/360695274/french-rugby-boss-says-les-bleus-stars-could-tour-they-target-series-win-against-all-blacks

                                      Realistically how many?

                                      Compare to an All Black Team without C, say, Chiefs and Saders.

                                      Groot
                                      Aumua
                                      Lomax
                                      Paddy T
                                      Holland
                                      Kirifi
                                      Iose
                                      Lakai
                                      Roigard
                                      Barrett
                                      Clarke
                                      Barrett
                                      Ioane/ Proctor
                                      Telea/Lam
                                      Love

                                      ?
                                      ?
                                      Tosi
                                      ?
                                      Savea / Papalii
                                      Christie (I know)
                                      Tavatavanawai / Lam / Tangitau / Taele

                                      Chris B.C Offline
                                      Chris B.C Offline
                                      Chris B.
                                      wrote on last edited by
                                      #2340

                                      @booboo I guess they've got a Top14 and we've got five-and-a-bit Super teams, so hopefully a bit less impact.

                                      boobooB 1 Reply Last reply
                                      2
                                      • Chris B.C Chris B.

                                        @mariner4life There's obviously some truth in what you say, but there's also some caveats.

                                        One is that we're never going to have 36 Richie McCaws in our squad. There's always going to be a continuum from the brilliant, to guys on the fringe who you wish were better.

                                        But, that doesn't mean picking the next cab off the rank will be (better). There's got to be a reasonable chance that he will be - otherwise, you're just selecting someone to "give them a go", with a risk that their "difference-making" will be to lose the match for you.

                                        It's pretty rare, IMO, that a brilliant young player gets ignored/missed for long. More likely you're shuffling the third choice and fourth choice guys.

                                        Sometimes, you're just better off with the journeymen. Case in point, 2011 RWC Final.

                                        The Fern would have shot Beaver and Andy Ellis into the sun if they'd had a rocket - but, in the end, they were guys who could do what was necessary.

                                        Contrast to probably 2007 and 2019, where the bright and shiny boys didn't quite have the resilience.

                                        And probably, the first Bok test last year, when we had the winning of the game until the last 10 minutes, when we had to roll out lots of guys with few tests between them and the Boks finished over the top of us.

                                        mariner4lifeM Offline
                                        mariner4lifeM Offline
                                        mariner4life
                                        wrote on last edited by
                                        #2341

                                        @Chris-B i feel like you are arguing a point i didn't make.

                                        Not everyone in a rugby team should be a superstar. You need a balance of flash fluffybunnies and workers.

                                        BUT

                                        Just because you are a "worker" doesn't mean you aren't good at core roles. If you are a loose forward worker who doesn't make dominant tackles or move bodies quickly at ruck time, then what good are you? Two of those guys i mentioned fit this to a tee. Work hard? yes. Do effective work once you get there? not so much.

                                        Likewise a back should be able to either distribute the ball well (hand or foot), or be a strong carrier (maybe defender as well), or be fucking quick. I am not sure the back i mentioned brings any of those skills to a high standard.

                                        Even teh workers need to be more than "solid" or that old fucking cliche "won't let you down". I think this is especially true for those earmarked as bench players.

                                        Also Beaver absolutely sums up what i am saying. Beaver was the best 10 in the country when he got the Chiefs to the GF and made the ABs. Turns out he wasn't actually good enough at the next level though and was rightfully rissolled. He was brought back only in the most dire of emergencies, and played the ultimate "limited skillset" game to squeak the narrowest of wins. And was never seen again. The everyman's fairytale.

                                        Chris B.C 1 Reply Last reply
                                        5
                                        • Chris B.C Chris B.

                                          @booboo I guess they've got a Top14 and we've got five-and-a-bit Super teams, so hopefully a bit less impact.

                                          boobooB Offline
                                          boobooB Offline
                                          booboo
                                          wrote on last edited by
                                          #2342

                                          @Chris-B said in All Blacks 2025:

                                          @booboo I guess they've got a Top14 and we've got five-and-a-bit Super teams, so hopefully a bit less impact.

                                          Essentially my point which I didn't make very well.

                                          1 Reply Last reply
                                          0
                                          Reply
                                          • Reply as topic
                                          Log in to reply
                                          • Oldest to Newest
                                          • Newest to Oldest
                                          • Most Votes


                                          • Login

                                          • Don't have an account? Register

                                          • Search
                                          • First post
                                            Last post
                                          0
                                          • Categories
                                          • Search